Your emails go to spam when inbox providers like Gmail see people ignoring, deleting or reporting them, or when your sending domain isn't set up the way they require. To fix it, check five numbers, send only to people who engage until those numbers are healthy, then add everyone else back in small batches.
This takes a few weeks of sends. Start before your biggest sends of the year, since those reach the most people who haven't opened in a while.
Step 1: Check your domain setup
Gmail requires bulk senders to set up SPF, DKIM and DMARC on their sending domain and to include a one-click unsubscribe link in marketing emails. If any of these are missing, Gmail can reject your emails or send them to spam.
Google Postmaster Tools shows whether your domain meets these requirements. It's free and needs a one-time DNS record to verify your domain. If you're on Klaviyo or another email platform, the platform's setup pages show whether your sending domain is verified.
Step 2: Check your 5 numbers
In Klaviyo, go to Analytics > Deliverability. It shows your open, click, bounce, unsubscribe and spam complaint rates for the last 30 days and rates each one. Each campaign report also has a Deliverability tab.
These are Klaviyo's targets:
| Number | Healthy | Needs attention |
|---|---|---|
| Open rate | Above 33% | Below 27% |
| Click rate | Above 1.2% | Below 0.8% |
| Unsubscribe rate | Below 0.3% | Above 1% |
| Spam complaint rate | Below 0.01% | Above 0.05% |
| Bounce rate | 1% or lower | Above 2% |
Two of these numbers need a second look.
- Spam complaints: Gmail doesn't share spam complaints with Klaviyo or other email platforms, so the rate in your email platform runs low. Check Gmail's rate in Google Postmaster Tools. Google says to keep it below 0.1% and never let it reach 0.3%. Above 0.3%, Gmail stops offering help with delivery problems until you've stayed below 0.3% for 7 days.
- Open rate: Apple Mail opens emails automatically for people who use its privacy setting, so your open rate runs high. Treat clicks as the more reliable number. Klaviyo marks these automatic opens with an Apple privacy open flag you can filter on.
Step 3: Send only to engaged subscribers
Build a segment of subscribed profiles who opened or clicked in the last 90 days. Send your campaigns to that segment only. If you send daily or several times a week, use 30 days.
Inbox providers watch how people react to your emails. When the people you send to open and click, your sender reputation improves and more of your emails reach the inbox.
Keep sending to this segment until your five numbers are in the healthy range. This usually takes a few weeks of sends.
Step 4: Add older contacts back in small batches
Once your numbers are healthy, add people who haven't engaged in a while. Add no more than 10% on top of your engaged segment per send. If 10,000 people are engaged, add up to 1,000 older contacts. If your numbers are close to the limits, add 5%.
Choose the older contacts by interest so the email fits them. For an email about hats, add people who viewed your hat pages at least twice.
Step 5: Check your numbers after each send
Before each new send, check how the last one did.
- Numbers still healthy: add the next batch, from a different interest group.
- Numbers below the targets: go back to sending only to your engaged segment until they recover.
Repeat until you've added back as many older contacts as your numbers allow.
Step 6: Stop sending to people who never engage
Profiles that haven't opened or clicked in months bring down your rates. Klaviyo's Deliverability hub can create a Never Engaged segment for you. Suppress that segment so those profiles stop getting campaigns, and add the same segment as an exclusion filter on your flows.
Klaviyo can disable accounts that keep sending campaigns with high spam complaint or unsubscribe rates.
Bonus: have Claude or ChatGPT do the checks for you
Claude and ChatGPT can read your Klaviyo account directly, pull the five numbers, and write a plan for your list. The setup takes about 5 minutes. You need an Owner, Admin or Manager role in Klaviyo.
Connect Klaviyo
- Claude: go to Settings > Connectors, select Browse Connectors, search for Klaviyo, connect and approve access.
- ChatGPT: add the Klaviyo app from Settings > Apps.
- The Klaviyo connection can also create and change campaigns, segments and flows. The prompts below tell the AI to read only. Review anything it suggests before you change your account.
Add your Gmail spam rate
Klaviyo can't see Gmail's spam complaints, so the AI won't have them either. Open Google Postmaster Tools, take a screenshot of your spam rate for the last 30 days, and attach it to the chat with the first prompt. Postmaster Tools has an API, and there are community-built connectors for it, but they need a Google Cloud setup. A screenshot is faster.
Prompt 1: check your account
Copy this into a new chat:
Use my Klaviyo account to check my email deliverability. Read only: don't create, edit or send anything. 1. Pull open rate, click rate, unsubscribe rate, spam complaint rate and bounce rate for my last 10 campaigns and for the account over the last 30 days. 2. Compare each number to these targets: open rate above 33%, click rate above 1.2%, unsubscribe rate below 0.3%, spam complaint rate below 0.01%, bounce rate 1% or lower. Mark each one healthy or needs attention. 3. Tell me how much of my open rate comes from Apple privacy opens. 4. I've attached my Google Postmaster Tools spam rate. Tell me if it's below 0.1%. 5. List my segments and their sizes. Tell me if I have an engaged segment (subscribed, opened or clicked in the last 90 days) and a never engaged segment. 6. Check whether my campaigns from the last 30 days went to an engaged segment or to my full list. 7. List my live flows and tell me which ones have no filter excluding unengaged profiles. Show the results in one table, then list the problems in order of how much they hurt deliverability.
Prompt 2: get a plan for your list
Send this in the same chat after the results come back:
Using those results, write me a plan to get my numbers healthy before my next big send on [date]. - Tell me exactly how to define my engaged segment and how many profiles it has. - Tell me how many sends at the engaged segment I need before my numbers are healthy, based on how far they are from the targets. - Split the older, unengaged profiles into interest groups using what they've viewed or bought, with the size of each group. - Give me a send schedule: each send's date, which segment and interest group it goes to, and how many profiles. Add no more than 10% of the engaged segment on top of each send, or 5% if any number is close to its limit. - Tell me which numbers to check after each send and what to do if they drop. - List the segments and flow filters I need to create, with the exact conditions, so I can build them myself.
The AI reads your data at the time you ask. Run prompt 1 again after each send to check your numbers before the next batch.
FAQ
How do I know if my emails are going to spam?
Send a campaign to a few Gmail, Outlook and Yahoo addresses you own and see where it arrives. Then check Google Postmaster Tools for your Gmail spam rate and Klaviyo's Deliverability hub for the rest.
My open rate looks fine. Can I still be in spam?
Yes. Automatic Apple Mail opens can make your open rate look healthy. Check your click rate and your Gmail spam rate as well.
How long does it take to get out of spam?
A few weeks of sending to engaged subscribers, depending on how far your numbers are from the targets.
Should I send to my whole list for Black Friday?
Send your biggest emails to your engaged segment and add older contacts only in the batches from step 4.